The AP Had It Right The First Time

Earlier this afternoon, "A housing issue: McCain not sure how many they own" was the top headline on Yahoo's front page. The opening paragraphs of the linked AP article were pure gold, proof that Obama and the blogs had successfully driven the narrative today:

Days after he cracked that being rich in the U.S. meant earning at least $5 million a year, Republican presidential candidate John McCain acknowledged that he wasn't sure how many houses he and his wealthy wife actually own.

"I think -- I'll have my staff get to you," McCain responded to a question posed by Politico, according to a story Thursday on the publication's Web site. "It's condominiums where -- I'll have them get to you."

Later, the McCain campaign told Politico that McCain and his wife, Cindy, have at least four in three states -- Arizona, California and Virginia. Newsweek recently estimated the two owned at least seven properties.

The article was credited to "DOUGLASS K. DANIEL, Associated Press Writer."

Cut to a few hours later. Now, clicking the link that was attached to the original story takes you to a different story altogether, a more recent one credited to "MATT APUZZO, Associated Press Writer" whose headline reads

Obama raps McCain for ignorance of his own houses

and instead begins:

John McCain may have created his own housing crisis. Hours after a report that the Republican presidential nominee-in-waiting didn't know how many homes he and his multimillionaire wife own, Democratic rival Barack Obama launched a national TV ad and a series of campaign stops aimed at portraying McCain as wealthy and out of touch.

With the economy ranking as the top issue in the race, Obama sought to turn McCain's gaffe into one of those symbolic moments that stick in voters' minds.

Think John Kerry sailboarding or the first President Bush wowed by a grocery store checkout scanner, Michael Dukakis riding in a tank or Gerald Ford eating a tamale with the husk still on.

"I think -- I'll have my staff get to you," McCain told Politico when asked Wednesday how many houses he owns. "It's condominiums where -- I'll have them get to you."

Not all bad, of course, but not as sweet from a narrative perspective as the original version (which you can read in its entirety on NewsVine HERE.) You'll notice that the first reference to John McCain's "$5 million" comment comes in the 6th paragraph, not in the first. Linking the $5 million dollar comment and the fact that McCain doesn't know how many homes he has was central to Obama's messaging today. The AP seems to have made an editorial decision to back away from reinforcing that.

I've heard of stories being updated, but how common is it for a  story to be updated to such a degree that both the headline and the writer are changed but the link stays the same?

If you do quote the article, use the original, again found at Newsvine HERE.



Display:


Second article is better (none / 0)

I disagree with you Todd. The second article drives home just how devastating this is, tying it to the scanner and the tank. I'd rather have people thinking "Wow, McCain really is out of touch...just like Bush Sr." then fixating on $5 million.


by elrod on Thu Aug 21, 2008 at 08:09:39 PM EST

NINE KEY RINGS!!! (none / 0)

HEY SOMEONE POST THIS FRONT PAGE, AND IF YOU ARE GOING TO THE CONVENTION MAKE THIS HAPPEN!!!!!!!!  

IT IS BRILLIANT:  SIMPLY PUT, REVENGE FOR PURPLE HEART BAND-AIDS:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ydusFDKdE 4o&eurl=http://talkingpointsmemo.com /archives/209622.php


by RuralD on Thu Aug 21, 2008 at 08:23:51 PM EST

Where's the credit for Brave New Films? (none / 0)

I'm kind of shocked that I haven't seen anyone credit Robert Greenwald and Brave New Films for broaching this entire topic -- 4 days ago. Isn't that where the reporter got the impetus for the question in the first place?:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ek3jAkx9m 10

McCain's Mansions:
http://therealmccain.com/?utm_source=rge mail


by JD Lasica on Thu Aug 21, 2008 at 09:34:09 PM EST

Re: The AP Had It Right The First Time (none / 0)

The second version is way way WAY better than the first mostly because it goes out of its way to define this gaffe as the kind of pivotal moment that gets mentioned throughout the entire campaign and permanently tars a candidate's image, invoking all the similar ghosts of campaign past -- Dukakis on Tank, Kerry on windsurfing board, Bush at checkout counter -- to make this point. Articles with that kind of attitude give the media carte blanche to weave this narrative throughout the entire rest of the coverage as established fact and that is exactly what we need. It's thinking like that that turns this narrative from a one-day news cycle victory that everyone will forget once the VP and convention buzz takes over and instead into a laugh line on Letterman and Leno every night until November, which is when it becomes conventional wisdom among the pundits and voters as well.


by dan panorama on Fri Aug 22, 2008 at 01:53:25 AM EST

Safe as Houses - a Prank (none / 0)

You've heard about the guy proposing that everyone at the Dem Convention next week be given nine keyrings with keys on them, supposedly the keys to McCain's houses.  Not a half bad idea, actually.

Another one: assuming it's possible to buy a shitload of Monopoly houses (think of the fat guy buying marbles at the end of Animal House), we scatter tons of them on the ground wherever McCain is due to show up, starting with the approaches to the GOP Convention next week in Minneapolis.


by RT on Fri Aug 22, 2008 at 06:25:13 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.